Replica: By the Fireplace vs Camp Fire

Side-by-Side Notes

How Camp Fire Compares to Replica: By the Fireplace

Put the two pyramids side by side and Camp Fire covers roughly 56% of Replica: By the Fireplace: 5 of 9 notes match. Both build around Pink Pepper, Chestnut, Guaiac Wood and Vanilla — the backbone that makes the resemblance work.

Camp Fire drops Clementine Pulp, Cloves and Flaming Rum and substitutes Clove, Orange Blossom and Juniper, which shifts the character in the dry-down. Note lists only tell part of the story — materials and dosage decide how close it actually smells, which is what our AI similarity score weighs.

Camp Fire Scores vs Replica: By the Fireplace

How We Score

AI Verdict

Camp Fire by Emir is a remarkably close interpretation of By the Fireplace. Both share the signature chestnut-guaiac wood-cashmeran backbone that defines the cozy hearth character. Emir substitutes orange blossom for clementine pulp, adding slight floral softness, while Peru balsam replaces musk for a richer, resinous dry-down. The clove-pink pepper opening is nearly identical. Camp Fire as an EDP projects slightly better and lasts longer. Missing is the flaming rum accord, making Emir marginally less smoky and complex. At $33 versus ~$170, the value proposition is exceptional for an 85-90% clone performance.

Frequently Asked Questions