Home / Replica: By the Fireplace / Camp Fire
Camp Fire ranks near the top of our Replica: By the Fireplace comparisons — 9/10 overall, for $33 against a $145 original, about 77% cheaper. Longevity holds up, 8/10 — not just a one-note similarity play.
AI Scores
AI Verdict
Camp Fire by Emir is a remarkably close interpretation of By the Fireplace. Both share the signature chestnut-guaiac wood-cashmeran backbone that defines the cozy hearth character. Emir substitutes orange blossom for clementine pulp, adding slight floral softness, while Peru balsam replaces musk for a richer, resinous dry-down. The clove-pink pepper opening is nearly identical. Camp Fire as an EDP projects slightly better and lasts longer. Missing is the flaming rum accord, making Emir marginally less smoky and complex. At $33 versus ~$170, the value proposition is exceptional for an 85-90% clone performance.
Fragrance Notes
Camp Fire vs Replica: By the Fireplace: The Notes
Put the two pyramids side by side and Camp Fire covers roughly 56% of Replica: By the Fireplace: 5 of 9 notes match. Pink Pepper, Chestnut, Guaiac Wood and Vanilla appear in both compositions and do most of the heavy lifting for similarity.
Where they diverge: Camp Fire skips Clementine Pulp, Cloves and Flaming Rum and leans on Clove, Orange Blossom and Juniper instead. Remember that identical note lists can smell different in practice; concentration and raw materials matter, and that's factored into the similarity score.
Similar Clones by Note Profile
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Camp Fire a good dupe for Replica: By the Fireplace?
Camp Fire by Emir scores 8/10 for similarity to Replica: By the Fireplace. With an overall score of 9/10, it is highly recommended.
What is Camp Fire a dupe of?
Camp Fire by Emir is a dupe of Replica: By the Fireplace — see the full original profile and all its ranked alternatives on our Replica: By the Fireplace page. It scores 8/10 for similarity.
Where can I buy Camp Fire?
Camp Fire is confirmed available to buy in India and the US (around $33) — the buy button above routes to a live listing, not a generic search.
How similar is Camp Fire to Replica: By the Fireplace?
Camp Fire has a similarity score of 8/10 compared to Replica: By the Fireplace, with a longevity score of 8/10 and value score of 10/10.
Also searched as: Camp Fire dupe · what is Camp Fire a dupe of · Camp Fire vs Replica: By the Fireplace · is Camp Fire a good dupe for Replica: By the Fireplace · Camp Fire clone of · Camp Fire review · Camp Fire smells like
Buy Camp Fire
Affiliate link — as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Any prices shown on this page are typical retail figures, not live retailer prices; check the retailer for current price and availability. How We Score
Contains affiliate links. We earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Camp Fire
9.0/10 overall