Silver Mountain Water vs Club de Nuit Sillage

Side-by-Side Notes

How Club de Nuit Sillage Compares to Silver Mountain Water

Club de Nuit Sillage matches 5 of the 9 notes in Silver Mountain Water — about 56% of the recipe. Both build around Bergamot, Mandarin, Green Tea and Musk — the backbone that makes the resemblance work.

Club de Nuit Sillage drops Neroli, Blackcurrant and Galbanum and substitutes Jasmine, Amber and Moss, which shifts the character in the dry-down. Note lists only tell part of the story — materials and dosage decide how close it actually smells, which is what our AI similarity score weighs.

Club de Nuit Sillage Scores vs Silver Mountain Water

How We Score

AI Verdict

Club de Nuit Sillage captures SMW's bright, aquatic-green citrus DNA convincingly, sharing bergamot, green tea, mandarin, and sandalwood. However, it lacks SMW's distinctive blackcurrant and neroli lift, replacing them with jasmine and amber, giving a warmer, slightly softer character. The opening is impressively close; the drydown diverges more noticeably. Sillage projects well and lasts 6–8 hours on skin, competitive with SMW. At $20–$60 versus Creed's $300+, the value proposition is exceptional. Not a perfect replica, but a highly wearable, respectable alternative for daily use.

Frequently Asked Questions