Star Men holds up as a credible A*Men pick, 7/10 overall in our scoring, for $28 against a $108 original, about 74% cheaper. Expect average wear time for the category, 6/10 on longevity.
AI Scores
AI Verdict
Star Men captures A*Men's core DNA reasonably well — the mint-coffee-caramel-patchouli backbone is recognizable, and the gourmand sweetness lands in similar territory. However, the clone lacks A*Men's distinctive tar and dark chocolate edge, which gives the original its gritty, iconic character. Star Men skews fruitier and more conventional, feeling safer and less edgy. As an EDP it theoretically projects longer, though reformulated clone bases often underperform. At $15–$40 it offers solid value for those wanting the A*Men vibe on a budget, though hardcore fans will notice the missing darkness immediately.
Fragrance Notes
Star Men vs A*Men: The Notes
Star Men matches 8 of the 12 notes in A*Men — about 67% of the recipe. The common ground is Mint, Coffee, Lavender and Caramel, which carries the recognisable core of the scent.
The differences are real, though — Eucalyptus, Star Anise and Tar from the original are absent, replaced in Star Men's pyramid by Fruity Notes, Spices and Cilantro. Published pyramids are a starting point — the AI verdict below weighs how these translate on skin.
Similar Clones by Note Profile
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Star Men a good dupe for A*Men?
Star Men by Fragrance World scores 6/10 for similarity to A*Men. With an overall score of 7/10, it is a solid alternative.
What is Star Men a dupe of?
Star Men by Fragrance World is a dupe of A*Men — see the full original profile and all its ranked alternatives on our A*Men page. It scores 6/10 for similarity.
Where can I buy Star Men?
Star Men is confirmed available to buy in India and the US (around $28) — the buy button above routes to a live listing, not a generic search.
How similar is Star Men to A*Men?
Star Men has a similarity score of 6/10 compared to A*Men, with a longevity score of 6/10 and value score of 8/10.
Also searched as: Star Men dupe · what is Star Men a dupe of · Star Men vs A*Men · is Star Men a good dupe for A*Men · Star Men clone of · Star Men review · Star Men smells like
Buy Star Men
Affiliate link — as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Any prices shown on this page are typical retail figures, not live retailer prices; check the retailer for current price and availability. How We Score
Contains affiliate links. We earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Star Men
7.0/10 overall